Days before Utah Convicted Murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner’s impending execution he claims to have reformed while in jail. Today, Gardner will continue his hearing before the Utah parole board in which he aims to have his sentence commuted to life in prison. The board will not be examining the legal process Gardner endured, or determining the morality of the death penalty. Instead the board will be looking at other circumstances including: what Gardner has done since incarcerated, his possibly traumatic childhood, former mental stability, and his plans to start a troubled youth farm. It seems quite interesting that Gardner’s life problems have all been resolved as his execution grows nearer. If Gardner’s mental illness was so severe it caused him to commit vicious murders, then how has it disappeared so easily? A psychosis developed to the point of multiple murders seems a little more serious then something that just goes away, never to return. Although Gardner stated during the hearing yesterday, ” This may sound a little odd, but I think I could walk out of here today and never get in trouble again”, he has not been shown to be a trusting and moral individual that we could believe, so yes it does sound odd (KSL). The board also commented that Gardner continued to be a problem while incarcerated, starting a riot, stabbing another prisoner, and trying to escape repeatedly. There seems to be little to nothing this man and his lawyers can do at this point. Perhaps if his legal team had made different defense choices during his trials he would not be at this point. Commutation failed.
Posts Tagged ‘death penalty’
Utah Convicted Murderer Ronnie Lee Gardner Shows a Sudden and Convenient Change of Heart Days Before his Execution
Does Ronnie Lee Gardner’s Firing Squad have immunity from Prosecution for Murder?
The location and procedures for the execution of Ronnie Lee Gardner are spelled out in Utah Code Annotated Section 77-19-10. This statute provides that “The executive director of the Department of Corrections or his designee shall ensure that the method of judgment of death specified in the warrant is carried out at a secure correctional facility operated by the department and at an hour determined by the department on the date specified in the warrant….If the judgment of death is to be carried out by firing squad…the executive director of the department or his designee shall select a five-person firing squad of peace officers. Compensation for … members of the firing squad … shall be in an amount determined by the director of the Division of Finance.”
Under the Utah Statute authorizing the Firing Squad, there appears that there is no immunity provision for a murder charge for the Firing Squad personnel.
Is this an oversight by the legislature or is immunity found elsewhere in the Utah Code? If you know the answer, please answer this question in the comment section of this blog. Certainly the employees of the Utah Department of Corrections need assurances that there is absolutely no criminal liability for participating in the Firing Squad.
Death Penalty Debate Surrounds Salt Lake City
On Friday April 23 Judge Robin Reese signed the death warrant setting the execution of Ronnie Lee Gardner by firing squad for June 18. Gardner’s lawyers have requested a delay of execution pending the newest appeal but there is little evidence to support that this will be granted. I was personally in the courtroom when Gardner audibly held back tears as he stated his preference for the firing squad. This was the most compelling part of the defense as the other information conveyed was worn-out and futile. The defense lawyers at one point had friends and family members of victim, Michael Burdell, proclaim his personal feelings against the death penalty to show that it would not be reparation for the injustice committed. The lawyers were unable to further this point as they failed to effectively answer Judge Reese’s repeated inquiries to whether or not the execution would serve as reparation to society. This case has gathered national news media attention, typically aligned against Utah and its ruling. Although the media may know little about Utah and may present a few falsities, they do provide a lot more support against the death penalty them Utahns themselves. Before the April 23rd hearing a small group of people gathered in the foyer at the Scott Matheson Courthouse to protest the legality and morality of the death penalty. The gathering was poorly attended as the media nearly outnumbered the attendants. Onlookers and courthouse personnel were very unaware of the purpose and unable to hear the speakers. The morality and justice provided by the death penalty is something to be decided by the State of Utah and/or the U.S. Government. However without effective protest and a much larger alignment against its use, the death penalty will continue to be implemented
Date Changed for Death Penalty Protest in Salt Lake City
The hearing to set the execution date for Ronnie Lee Gardner was continued by Judge Robin Reese. It is now scheduled for April 23rd. The protest against the death penalty along with the public launch of the Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty will also be moved to April 23rd. The protest will still take place outside the Scott Matheson Courthouse but will be in the morning around 9am.
Death Penalty Protest in Salt Lake City set for Monday April 12th
On April 12, 2010 the State of Utah will determine the method and date of the execution for Ronnie Lee Gardner. In 1985 Gardner was sentenced to death for the murder of attorney Michael Burdell and the serious wounding of Bailiff George Kirk while attempting to escape from the old Salt Lake County Courthouse. On that day Gardner was in court for a hearing concerning the charges of robbery and murder. Attempts to appeal the ruling have been denied but there may be future attempts at a higher level.
A coalition of groups against the use of the death penalty will be protesting outside the Scott Matheson Courthouse where the hearing will be taking place. The protest is being organized by the UTADP, Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, and will also be attended by religious groups and leaders, public interest groups and other organizations. A meeting of protestors will take place at 2pm in front of the Scott Matheson Courthouse. Other members of the public are welcome to attend and join the protest against the use of the death penalty.
Arraignment Set for Accused Utah Murderer Curtis Allgier
On April 12th Curtis Allgier will enter his plea in response to eight charges including the murder of a Utah State Corrections Officer. In June of 2007 Curtis Allgier, who was incarcerated at the time, was taken to the University of Utah Medical Center for an MRI Scan. The Corrections Officer escorting Allgier, Stephen Anderson, was killed by a gunshot wound from his own gun. Along with murder, Allgier is being charged with such crimes as aggravated robbery and three counts of attempted aggravated murder from the happenings that occurred after his alleged escape from the University of Utah Medical Center. In the state of Utah the death penalty is still in affect so the prosecution in this case may pursue the death penalty during the trial.
A KSL News video focusing on the preliminary hearing for Curtis Allgier can be seen here.
Firing Squad Still an Option for Utah Convicted Murderer
Since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976 the state of Utah has executed six prisoners. All six were given the choice of execution by firing squad, only two of which chose this method. In March of 2004 Utah banned execution by firing squad. However, any inmates already sentenced to death that had requested execution by firing squad could still be legally executed by firing squad. Although there is no official protocol for execution by firing squad in Utah it is commonly believed that five correctional officers will participate, each aiming at the inmates torso. Some of the officers will have blanks and some will have live ammunition, to disguise the actual person who committed the act. (Death Penalty Information Center)
Ronnie Lee Gardner, an inmate on death row in Utah, was sentenced to die in 1985 after being convicted of capital murder. Gardner was grandfathered into the former law allowing prisoners to choose if they would prefer execution by firing squad. On April 12, 2010 Gardner will go before a district judge and will choose how he will die. Gardner had previously requested death by lethal injection but he still has the right to choose death by firing squad. According to the Desert News Gardener stated in 1996, “I like the firing squad. It’s so much easier – and there’s no mistakes” (Morgan, Emiley Utah Death Row Inmate Could Die by Firing Squad)





